The Elks Lodge is a point of interest in Tonawanda, NY. Open: Mon, Tue, Sun Closed; Wed–Sat 4:00 – 11:00 PM. Phone: (716) 693-2225. Average rating is 4.5 stars from 74 reviews. Website: https://www.elks.org/lodges/ContactUs.cfm?LodgeNumber=0860.
Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks emblemTwin Cities, NY Elks Lodge #860
Call Now Directions
Review
A live band performing at The Elks Lodge.
4.5 74 reviews Today Closed

Brotherhood, Great Food, Cold Drinks in Tonawanda

Elks Lodge 860 on Main Street serves up legendary fish fry, weekly specials, and genuine community since 1902.

Charity

Giving without expectation

Justice

Fairness for every person

Brotherly Love

Fellowship above all

Fidelity

Faithful to our word

About Us

A street view of The Elks Lodge during a community event.
A street view of The Elks Lodge during a community event.

Friday nights at Elks Lodge 860 have a reputation that travels. The fish fry alone draws regulars who've been coming for years, and first-timers rarely leave without booking a return visit. Portions run generous, the wait for a table is almost unheard of, and the staff treats every guest like a member of the family.

Manager Dave has built something rare here: a dining room where the person running the kitchen also comes out to check on your table, and where his wife Colleen is likely your waitress. That kind of personal touch is the difference between a meal and an evening. Reviews consistently call it clean, friendly, and worth every dollar.

Beyond the dining room, Lodge 860 is a living part of Tonawanda, NY. The Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks has been rooted in this community for over a century, funding scholarships, veterans programs, and youth initiatives. Eating here means your dollars stay local and do real good.

What We Offer

The kitchen runs weekly specials that keep the menu interesting without ever losing the classics. Crew House Catering handles private events with the same care that goes into every regular-night plate, making the lodge a legitimate option for parties, fundraisers, and celebrations of all sizes.

The bar pours cold and the atmosphere stays lively without getting loud. Members and guests mix easily at 55 Main Street, whether it's a casual Thursday dinner or a ticketed lodge event. Check the lodge's event calendar for themed nights, holiday dinners, and community fundraisers that fill the calendar year-round.

Non-members are welcome as guests and can explore full membership to unlock access to member pricing, private events, and the satisfaction of belonging to one of America's oldest fraternal organizations. Membership applications are available on-site or through the national Elks portal.

Why Choose Us

Rated 4.5 stars across 74 reviews, with guests singling out portion size and friendly service every time.

No long waits for a table, even on busy Friday fish fry nights that pack other spots.

Crew House Catering brings the same quality kitchen to your private event, fundraiser, or celebration.

Manager Dave and his team personally check on every table, not just the ones near the host stand.

Lodge 860 channels membership dues and event proceeds directly into Tonawanda scholarships and veterans programs.

Over a century of presence in Western New York means deep roots and a community that shows up for each other.

Gallery

Take a look at our space and what we have to offer

What Our Guests Say

Don't just take our word for it - hear it from our members & guests

Click to Rate & Review This Business ✍️
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
a year ago
"I absolutely love the variety of food and the specials every week. I decided to try this restaurant over the summer 2024 . I have never had to wait for a table . The entire wait staff is very helpful and attentive. The food is amazing. I have tried several different dishes and several specials and they are all outstanding. The food is served hot and delicious. I look forward to going back again."
— mark hawn
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
a year ago
"Clean Elks lodge with delicious food. Met the manager Dave who was a delight. Came out to see how everything was. His wife Colleen was our waitress. She was super friendly and helpful. My fish fry was great and my husband had the lobster ravioli which was delicious. Very reasonable prices. It's a family run business. Their two older sons in the kitchen with Dad and their youngest was our host. Will definitely be coming back here. It was a packed house when we we're there."
— Michael Lenney
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
a year ago
"The food is delicious! The portions are amazing. Fun atmosphere! I would highly recommend Crew House Catering. Thank you Dave and Colleen for a wonderful night out! We will definitely be back!"
— Cindy Krajacic
⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 years ago
"1st time customer here. They definitely need to hire more staff. One bartender and one host.. There had to be over fifty people in this place on a Saturday night. Food was exceptional.I had the clam chowder for an appetizer and the roast beef and 5 chicken wings for dinner. Very much above average."
— Christopher
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
7 years ago
"Food was delicious. Had the baked Florentine broiled fish and new England clam chowder. Service was excellent and the ambiance wasn't too loud. Excellent portion sizes also. We will definitely go again!! :)"
— Sophia-Katherine Wroblewski

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to be an Elks member to eat at the lodge?

Non-members are welcome as guests of the lodge. You can dine, attend events, and enjoy the bar without a membership card. If you love the atmosphere, ask about becoming a member for additional perks and member pricing.

What is the fish fry like, and when is it served?

The fish fry is a Friday tradition at Lodge 860 and one of the most talked-about items in the reviews. Portions are large, the fish is consistently praised, and tables typically turn over smoothly without long waits.

Can I book a private event or party at the lodge?

Yes. Crew House Catering operates out of Lodge 860 and handles private events including parties, fundraisers, and corporate dinners. Contact the lodge directly through the Elks national contact page to discuss availability and pricing.

What are the weekly specials?

Specials rotate throughout the week and have been a big reason guests keep coming back. The best way to stay current is to follow the lodge's announcements or call ahead to ask what's on for the evening.

Where is Elks Lodge 860 located?

The lodge is at 55 Main Street in Tonawanda, NY 14150, easily accessible from the surrounding North Buffalo and Tonawanda neighborhoods.

How do I become a member of Elks Lodge 860?

Membership is open to U.S. citizens who believe in God and are at least 21 years old. You can start the process by visiting the Elks national website at elks.org or by speaking with a lodge officer on your next visit to Main Street.

Does the lodge support any community programs?

Absolutely. The BPOE has a long record of funding local scholarships, supporting veterans, and running youth programs. Lodge 860 participates in these national initiatives while also giving back specifically to the Tonawanda community.

Hours of Operation

Closed · Opens Wednesday at 4:00
Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Thursday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Friday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Saturday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Sunday Today Closed
The Order · Since 1868

Community. Friendship. Charity.

Every Elks lodge belongs to one of America's oldest and largest fraternal orders. Through the Elks National Foundation, the Order has given more than $481 million to college scholarships, veterans, and neighbors in need.

Join the Elks
A Proud Heritage

The Elks gave America
Flag Day.

Long before it was a national observance, the Order set aside June 14th to honor the flag. Patriotism has always been one of our cardinal principles, and every lodge meeting still closes the same way it has for over a century.

“To our absent members.” — the Eleven O’Clock Toast

Get In Touch

Ready to get started? Contact us today!

Save to Contacts

Around the neighborhood

Other places near here, whatever their type.

Elks Lodge
★ 4.5 (19)
3.1 mi Association Or Organization Kenmore, NY
Elks Lodge
★ 4.7 (57)
6.2 mi Niagara Falls, NY
Community Action Organization of WNY (CAO of WNY)
★ 4.1 (31)
6.2 mi Association Or Organization Kenmore, NY
District 37 Kitchen & Taphouse
★ 4.6 (804)
0.2 mi American Restaurant North Tonawanda
Rainbow Rink Skating & Entertainment Center
★ 4.4 (925)
0.5 mi Sports Complex North Tonawanda
Dockside Bar & Grill
★ 4.2 (1,936)
0.3 mi Restaurant North Tonawanda
Mississippi Mudds
★ 4.3 (2,101)
0.6 mi Ice Cream Shop Tonawanda
Remington Tavern and Seafood Exchange
★ 4.5 (1,899)
0.3 mi Seafood Restaurant North Tonawanda

Contact The Elks Lodge

Send a note and The Elks Lodge will get back to you. No account needed.

Add an email or a phone so they can reply.

Best time to reach you
Community · Friendship · Charity

Who are the Elks?

The Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks is one of America's oldest and largest fraternal orders, founded in 1868. Every lodge is a home for fellowship, service, and patriotism in its own hometown.

$481M+given through the Elks National Foundation for scholarships, veterans, and community programs.

What the Order does

Report an issue

See something off? Tell us. We’ll fix it and improve the listing for everyone. No account required.